Above Castro & 18thThe Catty, the Chatty, the Boring, the Adoring;
The Cold, the Official, and the Heart's Outpouring.
About this Entry
Posted by: ABloggingHorse

Visit ABloggingHorse's Xanga Site

Original: 2/1/2009 1:03 AM
Views: 110
Comments: 8
eProps: 12

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site



Sunday, February 01, 2009

A Different Twist on the Economy

 by Daniel Culveyhouse

The housing market in the United States turns upside-down, and a subprime mortgage crisis ravages banks and homeowners. Then, six months later, Asian stock markets collapse, Iceland's economy and government crumble, and the entire world reels under a very bad recession. While watching these events unfold, no one could really say that life in 2009 is grand, not by any stretch of the imagination.  You don't have to walk far to hear people crying, whining, complaining, and lamenting the loss of their jobs, or maybe their homes, and possibly their sanity.

Would you believe that most of our ancestors would turn in their graves if they could hear us griping about our recent misfortune? To them, life was something to savor for the moment, since amidst the frequent chaos and turbulence of the 20th century, no one knew what the next day would bring.  Our grandparents could only fantasize about the kind of lives that we enjoy today, and that perspective from an age long gone seems to be overlooked, especially now, in such a dark hour. Let's explore this incitement a little further:

The first example to put current events into perspective is a great one.  It was called... well, The Great Depression. We have no idea what it was like to suffer through an economic meltdown during the 30s, right alongside other calamities such as major droughts and the American Dust Bowl.  That anyone managed to pass through this period with dignity and hope is a miracle in my opinion. Our market corrections should feel like but a bump in the road compared to the "Dirty Thirties".    

If this isn't enough to convince you that our misfortune is only minor, try understanding conditions in Europe during World War I. From 1914 to 1918, European soldiers from nearly every country were embroiled in grisly trench warfare, which many of them considered worse than death itself. The grim conditions in the trenches— incessant shelling, raids, sniper attacks, diseases, infections, and poison had caused millions of deaths by the time the first world war ended.  For a horrifying glimpse at life in the trenches, watch the first half-hour of A Very Long Engagement, a French film by Jean-Pierre Jeunet.  Trust me, after watching this, the recession will feel like just another cloudy day to you.

The citations go on throughout history. How would you like to have been among the first Jamestown settlers in 1607, where only one third of your friends would survive the first two winters (if you were luckily enough to survive yourself). Lastly, how would you like to have been one of over TEN MILLION Jews sent to internment camps throughout Europe during World War II, and to have known that over half of your fellow Jews would not survive to the end of the war.

I think I would choose this recession over any of these dark chunks of history. How about you?   


It takes some insight into history— just a little— to place your current situation into perspective, whatever that situation may be. We enjoy so many modern comforts that were absent just a few decades ago, that it's almost a travesty to complain about any hardship.  We can still laugh, we can share our discomfort and support each other, and we can learn from our tumultuous past to limit this recession (and apply modern economics to stave off a full depression). And best of all, by using a little foresight, we can see before us a very bright and prosperous decade to come.



 Posted 2/1/2009 1:03 AM - 110 Views - 12 eProps - 8 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

8 Comments

Visit Fatcat723's Xanga Site!
Well done. Thanks. I love history and know that we forget how fortunate we really are. Yes, could be better. I feel we were living large and wanting more and more, forgetting about what is really essential for life. Maybe it is time to be taught. Well done - good entry.
Posted 2/1/2009 4:11 AM by Fatcat723 Xanga Premium Member - reply

Visit junshien's Xanga Site!
Very true words, my friend.
Posted 2/1/2009 6:01 AM by junshien Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - reply

Visit ElusiveWords's Xanga Site!
Nice entry. I remember the stories from my parents on how they endured the war. It robbed them of their childhood and they had to learn how to survive. I also watched how my parents endured some tough stretches when we came to Canada. Those that are tough, resourceful and can adapt will survive.
Posted 2/1/2009 6:02 PM by ElusiveWords Xanga True Member - reply

Visit christao408's Xanga Site!

Interesting perspective.  While it may be true that on a macro scale, this economic depression may be small potatoes compared with horrors that have come before, that's cold comfort to an individual who has been laid off, has no prospects of employment, a family to take care of and a mortgage to pay.

Yes, it could be worse.  But that doesn't mean that it isn't bad now.

Posted 2/1/2009 7:00 PM by christao408 Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - reply

Visit christao408's Xanga Site!

After a few hours' reflection, I just want to clarify that I do agree with you that those who are comparing this to the Great Depression, etc. are overstating the severity of the current situation.  I just don't want to diminish the pain or anxiety of those who are caught up in the financial downturn by saying "Oh, we've seen worse."

There was an interesting quote in Matt Bai's article in this weekend's NY Times Magazine that I think sums up the point well:

"Such facile comparisons between one moment and another inevitably lead to policy prescriptions that are stuck in the past. ... Worse yet, we begin to forge a kind of moral equivalency with the past to which we’re not entitled.  We begin to feel and talk as if we are enduring the depression that forged one of America’s bravest and most accomplished generations, when really we have no idea of the hardships that made those Americans and the country more responsible and more resolute."

Cheers.

Posted 2/1/2009 9:35 PM by christao408 Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - reply

Visit Wangium's Xanga Site!
I think the media has overstated the severity, which in turn made the mass hysterical

It truly was not that bad until all the media coverage
Posted 2/3/2009 10:45 AM by Wangium - reply

Visit vsan79's Xanga Site!
That is true, we need to thankful for what we have now.
Posted 2/5/2009 5:43 AM by vsan79 - reply

Visit laurac44's Xanga Site!

I agree - very well said.  I also think where there's a will, there's a way.  When you are faced with hardship, you find out just how strong you are, and how little you really need to survive. 

Posted 2/6/2009 5:52 PM by laurac44 - reply


Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to ABloggingHorse's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in ABloggingHorse's local time zone:
GMT -08:00 (Pacific Standard - US, Canada)